People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Always on time, always great. Kids love the sauce. Its out favorite tallmadge pizza place. ”
“ Food was delicious and the people are very nice! Shawn always does a nice job making sure the orders always look great! Not sure how anyone can leave a bad review. They always make it right! Thanks Romeos Tallmadge! ”
“ Meatball sub with extra meatballs only1more and extra cheese. Makes for a great sub . One thing I can say about Romeos is they care about quality. You can definitely tell. Thank you Romeos. April 2nd 2025 update literally the best pizza in the area. Hands down ”
“ Love the half sheet pizza!! Awesome food and I usually hate pizza sauce but love theirs its the bomb!! Would recommend the sheet pizza to anyone! If youre looking for a great pizza place this is it! Ive eaten at tallmadge and Hartsville locations! Both get a . Sorry dont have pictures cuz we dig in and eat before thinking about it!! LoL ”
“ First Time ordering from Romeos Pizza and Im very satisfied. Received my pizza Hott.!!! Update Ordered the Great Ranch and Potatos Pizza! It was Absolutely Fabulous, didnt think I would like Potatos on a pizza but it was yummy. A perfect combination of ingredients with caramelized onions, bacon, almonds, cheese blend, more bacon and a bacon ranch sauce! The Dough, Sauce, Cheese and Toppings were very good. I had the pizza cooked well done, recommend trying if you havent, it adds like a smokey flavor and crispiness to the pizza. The special Large 2 Toppings 12.00 which is an Awesome Deal. Great Job ”
“ First time ordering from Romeos and my family loved the pizza! Will definitely be going back! ”
“ I absolutely LOVE their pizza! The crust has a really good flavor and is always baked right. The sauce is sweet and has a rich tomato flavor which makes it taste authentic. When you order toppings, they give them and theyre not stingy either. I love the garlic butter they offer to dip the crust in..lol They have a full menu of other items but Im definitely addicted to the pizza! Staff is always nice and the prices are pretty standard. Definitely keeps me going back! ”
“ Always a enjoyable experience. Great food. ”
Menu
Italiano - Build Your Own
$18.23Romeos Deluxe
$14.81Buffalo Chicken
$14.81Great Ranch and Potato
$14.81New York White
$14.81
About
Romeo's Pizza Tallmadge
Welcome to Romeo's Pizza Tallmadge, a gem nestled in the heart of Tallmadge, Ohio, at 31 Erie Rd, where every pizza lover's dream comes true. If you're craving mouthwatering pizza and delectable sides, you've found the right place. Renowned for their commitment to quality and outstanding customer service, Romeo's Pizza Tallmadge consistently earns rave reviews from satisfied patrons.
With a simple phone call at (330) 630-5800, you can dive into a menu filled with a tempting array of options. Imagine indulging in their signature Calzone or Stromboli, bursting with flavors from traditional ingredients - pepperoni, salami, ham, and provolone - all generously topped with garlic butter and Romano cheese. For cheese aficionados, the Cheese Maniac is a must-try, featuring a savory combination of cheddar, white American, and provolone cheeses.
- Wings: Enjoy traditional bone-in wings tossed in your choice of sauce, available for just $10.25.
- Sauces: Enhance your meal with a range of dipping sauces, including the creamy Capone Sauce or the famed Aw Award Winning Pizza Sauce.
Customer reviews echo the passion behind every dish offered. Kevin McQuillen describes Romeo's as the go-to for his family, highlighting their outstanding sauce. Pamala Hoskins raves about their half-sheet pizza, admitting to digging in before taking a picture, a testament to the irresistible nature of the food. Robert Fischer and G Scott also chime in, appreciating the attention to detail and the unique flavor combinations that elevate the pizza experience.
Romeo's Pizza Tallmadge is not just another pizza place. It's a culinary haven where quality meets comfort. Whether you're feeding the family or treating yourself to a special meal, the warm environment and dedicated staff ensure that every visit leaves you satisfied. Don't miss the chance to explore their incredible offerings, from vibrant pizzas to flavorful sides - a true treat for all pizza enthusiasts!
Book a table